This post that was quoted has been deleted.
I would agree with most of that but add with the property on C and D you get far more property and land for your money and it's less cramped. Also some people prefer to stay away from the busy bars and shops in A and B and love the countryside walks etc.. The main route in is susceptible to floods, but only once or twice a year and it's resolved quickly if it is cut off. So that's the other side of the argument.